What to Expect From a Broken Clavicle

The following is a funny story sent to me by a rider that broke her collar bone while cycling. She found my site when searching for more information on training and recovery from the break.

Along with the story she mentions “I know it would’ve helped me alot if this information had been available when I was lost in the land of one arm. I have attached my ridiculously long account”. She then adds that I may post the story if I wish.

Well, I think it’s well worth posting. So here it is.

Enjoy.

DISCLAIMER: The following content is for informational purposes only. The content is not intended as a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Diagnosis and treatment of all health conditions should only be performed by your doctor or other licensed health care professional. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read on this site.

What to Expect From a Broken Clavicle

By Laura Erker

On March 23rd I had the exciting experience of breaking my left clavicle while riding my bike. I thought I’d put together a synopsis of what to expect so that anyone else can read and see what’s in store. If you’re reading this and you have broken you clavicle then get someone to run out to the store and get you some really good calcium. You should take 2000mg of calcium with 6mg of Boron a day! While they’re at it, have them pick you about four books to read and ten movies to go through. Further, a really funny account of the first five days with a broken clavicle can be found on line http://www.kurlancheek.com/clavicle.htm. Also, relax, it’s gonna be a while.

So, what happened? Good question, everyone has their own version of who is to blame and how it all went down. From my vantage point I only know that I was cruising along in a group, riding into a crosswind. Someone had the bright idea to put it in the gutter and everyone started fighting for wheels. Then, I heard some tires hit and “…zzt zzzt zzt crack crack crack”. The bike in front of me came to a screeching halt and as I hit my brakes I went into a skid that had my back wheel hit the back tire in front of me. Next thing I knew I was picking myself up off the ground and getting back on my bike. But, as I rode away I realized that something was very wrong. Not only was my left shoulder ON FIRE with pain but I could feel/hear a clicking there that could only be a broken bone. Deciding that I was not stupid enough to try to ride the remaining 25 miles with a broken bone I attempted to bring myself to a stop and threw my bike in the dirt glad to be rid of that infernal pain machine. The pain was so intense now that fainting was the only possibility. But, I had to wait to lose all consciousness until I could hail down an ambulance, cab, person! I could see a group of cars a mile away down the road at the site of the crash, where I should have stayed. Well, hindsight is always 20/20. I hailed the ambulance like a cab and crawled in just in time to faint. I was then transferred to another ambulance and so began my new adventure into a one-armed existence.

The emergency room was exciting and the staff was very generous. All in all, a three hour affair in the door and out. It ends up I broke the distal third of my collar bone. However, getting a hold of someone to pick me up became a new challenge. I didn’t have my cell phone with me and not knowing any phone numbers I had to go on the internet to get the number of my team director, Chris Evertsen. Chris or an official was able to relate to my husband where I was located and he headed off to get me. After sitting in the emergency entrance for hours, seeing my husband come through the door of the emergency room was one of the happiest moments of my life!

Week 1 (This is movie week)

One quickly learns that it is a two-armed world out there and this will not make your broken clavicled life any easier. But, on with life.

Killing the pain. First, let’s discuss the power of alchohol. Through the ages this fine substance has been used to dull the pain of many a fallen soldier. Seeing myself as such, I broke into the whiskey with wild abandon. Choosing Jack Daniels’ as my personal “fav’ I set out to imbibe. If you dose this correctly you won’t have to pick up your prescription vicadin. Careful to drink a glass of water for each alcoholic drink so you avoid hangovers.

Dressing, this becomes a new adventure. You must keep your hurt shoulder extremely still. This means that the arm attached to it is completely useless. If you are a woman then forget the bra. If you must have a bra get someone you “trust’ to put your most comfortable one on and realize you will be wearing this item for at least two or three days. Unable to work out how to get a t-shirt on I tried my shirts that button up. You soon come to realize that buttons are not an option. Ok, back to regular shirts. I could get large t-shirts on by feeding the sleeve of the bad arm over my useless hand up to my armpit and then carefully pulling it over my head and then putting my functional arm in the other arm hole. Getting the t-shirt off again is usually a two-person project. Forget tying shoelaces or wearing tight pants, they become the enemy.

Sleeping. Most certainly, one must avoid, at all costs, rolling onto the affected shoulder during the first week. This will wake you up in just as much pain as the day you crashed. I found that propping pillows all along the length of my body helped to reduce unwarranted movement. I slept a lot, there wasn’t much else to do. But, this doesn’t really matter, as dressing, eating, and drinking will take about 5 times longer than usual, so I filled my day accordingly.

Book read: Foundation by Isaac Asimov
Movies watched: a lot!
Alcohol consumption: can’t accurately remember :’)

Week 2

Now I was really starting to feel better, less pain in the shoulder and I could use my hand a bit. But my shoulder turned a pallid green. The bruising is disgusting and continued to creep down my torso for another week. But, since I only owned three t-shirts that I could manage to pull over my arm and head I just continued with the same state of affairs. It was about now that I realized I only had one thing to do to entertain myself!go to work. So, off I went arm in sling. I had only two things on my “to do” list each day. These items were usually something that would normally take me about an hour. Not now, I could spend all day working on simple problems. I had to get people to open the freezers for me and handle mice etc! But I got to talk with everyone at work quite a bit :’). I’d be able to work about 6 hours maximum a day before I completely cracked. This is when I learned to value of ibuprofen! One little pill can take a cranky/pained Laura and turn her into a working machine for about 2 more hours, lovely.

Comraderie. It was now that I learned that walking around in a sling attracts a lot of attention. People have to comment. They can’t help it.

“Fall off a bar stool?”
“Boy, broken collar bone, that’s the worst!”

I quickly pointed out that being on fire would probably be worse, but ok it’s nice to know people care.

I also learned that other injured people are most certainly your friend. You have to ask them what they did, and if they have a good left arm then you always ask if you could borrow it, or something corny like this. But, it’s fun.

I also started to get on the bike at the gym around this time. According to one man, I was great inspiration working out with my sling on. Well, I’d surely give up my inspiration status to use my left arm again, buddy! I went home suddenly after some of these visits to the gym because I would try to do too much and BLAM, pain again. Don’t do sit ups.

Doctor visit. It was mid-week that I was able to go and see a doctor. I sat there for about an hour just to get a referral to an orthopedist. Once I got in to see the nurse she looked straight at me (let me remind the reader that I was wearing my left arm in a sling and was covered with a big green bruise that covered my arm and torso)!

“So, what is your problem, today?”
“I have a broken clavicle and need to be referred to an orthopedist”
“Which arm is broken?”
(again, I remind the reader that my left arm was is a sling)
“My left arm”
“Okay, and what are you doing for it?”
I point to the sling, flabbergasted.
“When did it happen?”
“One week ago” I replied.
Surprised, “And you haven’t been in to see a doctor yet?”
“Well, no, I was just starting to feel like I could venture out of my “healing cocoon’.”
“Alright, let’s get you an appointment. Right, so the soonest our orthopedist can see you will be April 22nd.”
“That’s in three weeks! I have a broken bone. Isn’t there something sooner?”
“There isn’t really anything we can do for that, do you have any ibuprofen?”

Eventually I got x-rayed and was told to come back in three weeks.

Book Read: Second Foundation, Isaac Asimov

Week 3

I felt the same as Week 2 but was able to get on the trainer with my sling. I got a workout regimen from Hans Kellner on line. Very nice guy, who broke his clavicle a while back, you can go to !

Hans Kellner Dot Com :: Broken Clavicle No More

The training regimen consists of workouts broken up by Week 1, Week 2, and Week 3. Wow, I thought, this guy was training at week 1. Well, straight onto the trainer then, let’s get to work. Ends up, “Week 1” should be approached more as “the first week he began training after the break”. Holding my entire upper body up on my bike trainer with just my right arm was another challenge I hadn’t anticipated. I pushed through it. Also, it seems it only took Hans three weeks to recover, that’s only as long as his workout regimen was. Excellent, I’ll only be on the trainer for one week! This is great. Again, it ends up the three week training regimen can be repeated ad infinitum until you heal, just a little heads up.

Pit of Despair. This probably only applies to women. I could not shave the injured arm’s pit! This was horrible and I began to refer to this area of my body as the “pit of despair”. This is when you realize the ultimate greatness of the Mach 3 razor. You can literally shave without lifting your arm! Well lift it as much as you can. Good luck girls!

Book read: Swimming Across by Andrew Grove

Week 4

Having contracted some kind of horrible cold (which I affectionately call “the snot blanket”) I was unable to sleep at night or workout. I fell into a depressive mood. Out of desperation I rode my bike on the road for one hour and ended up hurting it again. This is when I completely cracked under the strain of heading out into the world each and every day facing new painful challenges. I was tired of it. I wanted just one day where I didn’t have to struggle to get my clothes on or sleep! I felt that no one could possibly understand the pain I was going through. It was during this time that a friend and coworker died in a tragic car accident. Suddenly I found myself very appreciative of my situation. I was alive, fairly healthy and had people that loved me.

Back to riding, I found that I couldn’t reach the handlebars with my bad arm until the end of Week 4, this may be because I had a distal break, but I don’t know. I just kept focusing on my appointment with the doctor and the x-ray machine. He would certainly tell me that I was completely healed and I could resume my life again. Alas, it was not to be, the x-ray looked the same as the day I broke my arm. Well, I headed back home to cry, pulled myself together, bought a year’s supply of calcium and vowed not to drink any alcohol until I was better and healed! I hear alcohol can reduce your healing abilities. Also, when you break a bone you should take 2000mg of calcium a day with 6mg of Boron.

This was the week that I talked with Dr. Allan Richberg, also a cyclist. He informed me that seeing no healing after four weeks was normal for a 30 year old. This greatly lifted my spirits! He talked with me for a good 30 minutes on what to expect from my injury. He informed me that if you ride in the early healing stages of a broken clavicle you will most probably put a rib into your lung if you crash. This was alarming, why didn’t my doctor tell me this. Thanks Allan!

Book read: Hitch Hiker’s Guide to the Galaxy by Doug Adams

Week 5

My arm started to feel a lot better now. I could lift it over my head! Also, I could start driving my car with two hands. This was great! I started really riding the trainer a lot and was able to just get my left hand up to the bars comfortably and put a little weight on it. I did seven hours on the trainer this week, good for me. Whoever thought I’d be riding my trainer so much in So Cal with it sunny and 80F outside!

Book read: Finished Hitch Hiker’s Guide

Week 6

I risked a ride on the road, against the doctor’s orders and found that my arm was ok. Whew!

Book read: Sequel to Hitch Hiker’s guide “Restaurant at the End of the Universe” by Doug Adams

Week 7

Now I am back to riding 3 times a week and really enjoying it. My body sure is tired though.

Book read: Finished Restaurant at the End of the Universe by Doug Adams

Week 8

I have an appointment with the doctor to get x-rayed again. Keep your fingers crossed. I am really looking forward to racing and just glued my ksyriums with the help of the best husband in the world, Jacob Erker.

Book read: Started Ringworld by Larry Niven

More “Broken Collar Bone” Articles

Don’t miss reading the information and comments in the other collar bone entries:

759 responses

  1. Jennie Avatar
    Jennie

    Here’s an interesting story I have a definite broken clavicle bone but don’t remember breaking it. Well thats not completely true I was in a car accident over 6 years ago which all I thought happened to me was just some bumps and bruises. However, I saw a family doctor who suggested that it was a delayed response ????? Does that make any sense to any one else? So one morning in October of last year I woke up felt my collar bone and there it was a pushed out bump. Let me tell you I was freaked out. I am currently trying to make an appointment with a Ortho doctor to maybe figure out this mystery. In your research have you found that this is a bump that I will have to live with for the rest of my life?
    Sincerely,
    Jennie

    It’s rather odd that a collar bone bump would appear so long after the accident. And it’s the first time here anyone has mentioned that happening. It’s good that you are seeing a doc about the bump. Let us know what the Ortho tells you.

    As for living with a collar bone bump, the good news is that the bump tends to decrease over time. Some folks lose the bump while others retain a slight bump. But it all depends on your own body. And having a bump isn’t so bad. It really makes for great stories when hanging around the pool.

  2. Colleen Pope Avatar

    Hey Casandra, I think men’s everyday necessities differ a lot from women’s! I do have to admit that my everyday necessities have become every-other-day necessities (like bathing/shaving) because it’s just too much of an ordeal. I’m looking forward to getting out of the tub and back into the shower. lol
    If they immobilize me….I’ll make them do it over my bra….I’m 37 too!!! Good tip about cocktails and painkillers….there’s nothing like washing down a couple of percs with a beer to wash away the pain and get a half-decent night’s sleep. Take care.

  3. Casandra Avatar
    Casandra

    I am so happy to have found this site. I broke my right clavicle 5 months ago today. It was the first day of spring break and I was feeling strong and healthy. That lasted until I rode my bike around a corner to fast, hit a guardrail, and did a header over the handle bars. The first orthopedic I went to put me in a really uncomfortable sling and told me I would need to wear it for 6 weeks. He spent a total of 3 minutes with me. After 4 weeks I was finally able to get into the otho that I wanted to go to. He told me I should have had surgery immediately after the accident – but now it was too late. When I saw him again the next month and I still had pain and had not even started to heal, he booked me for surgery.
    Surgery went well. I got a titanium plate and 8 screws put into my clavicle. When I had my follow up visit a week later – still taking lots of pain meds – I did not really understand him when he told me I needed to wear my sling for a while every day, but could use my arm for day to day necessities. I think my everyday necessities were a little different from what he had in mind and 4 weeks to the day of my surgery four of the screws ripped out of my bone and the plate started coming up through the top of my sholder. I barged into his office crying in pain and was taken immediately back to surgery. I am now 8 weeks since my second surgery and still wearing an “immobilizer” around my waist that secures my arm and wrist to the side of my body. For the first 6 weeks I was not allowed to take it off at all – thank god for tube tops that I could pull up underneath the immobilizer. I am now back to wearing real shirts (and a bra) as I can remove my immobilizer 2x a day. I have started back to work on a limited basis. I work with behavior disorder kids, so I am needed to keep my distance from most of them. I also have a bone growth stimulator that I wear 6 hours a day as my bones are not growing / healing. (My doctor also neglected to tell me not to drink after my first surgery, so I spent my summer vacation in a nice haze of pain pills and cocktails.) At 37 I am being told that I am at the upper eschlon of healing time. But I am tired of waiting!!! It is nice to commisterate with others. Good luck, speedy recovery, and oh yeah, curtail the cocktails for now.

  4. Colleen Pope Avatar

    Hey Trevor, I hear you about the ache, sometimes it’s unbearable. I dread night time, since I seem to toss & turn all night but am unable to toss & turn very far and not without groaning every time either. I avoided laying on my back the first couple of weeks because it was too painful to get up even with help. I found that my lower abdomen muscles were getting a good workout because they were doing most of the work.
    I am quite lucky that my worst accidents were on my dirt bike and not on the street (I also have a Honda 599 which I think is called the Hornet in your area of the world.)
    Good news for me, my doctor just called and they are trying to schedule me in to see an orthopedic specialist as early as next week. Keep posting how you’re doing….people who haven’t had this injury don’t always understand and some of the ones who have, it was too long ago for them to remember exactly how much this sucks!!!

  5. Trevor Avatar
    Trevor

    Hi again Colleen
    Due to the residual paralysis I have on that side It’s always difficult to get a clear view. My break has not really been painful and the consultant pressed the tenting bone last week and it was just like he was pushing a sponge that bounced back up, very strange and painless. I have limited movement under normal circumstances and although I can take my arm out of the sling for washing and dressing I’m very wary of moving it. Trying to hold my dropped shoulder up does make it ache. The worst bit for me is that if I try to lay on my unaffected side in bed then it’s too painful on the broken side. Also, I think I’ve strained my chest ligaments and it really hurts when raising myself from flat on the bed. Apart from all that I’m fine (he said jokingly!)
    I’m a big bike fan myself, mainly speedway, but I’m at one with all bike riders. I also know about biker pain after nearly killing myself on a road bike.
    I hope you lose that pain and get sorted out!

  6. Colleen Pope Avatar

    Good luck Steven, I hope your surgery goes well and you can get back to work quickly. I couldn’t find any previous posts from you…how did you break yours?

  7. Steven Avatar
    Steven

    Well I was sure mine would have healed by now, but No.
    It is now week 11 and the Doc said it is time to try surgery, so Next week I go in. I am going to have The Modified Hagie pin procedure That A DR. from Duke medical center in North Carolina came up with. It looks minuminly invasive and they say recovery is quicker. I have not been able to work at all through this because I am a Heavy Equipment Tech. That has really hurt since I am the main income in the house. and any disability you can get takes months to start.
    I have noticed that over the past couple weeks I can do more, but he still thinks for me surgery is best. I can not sit and wait any longer, I have to get back to work.
    Wish me luck, and I will let you know how this Modified pin procedure works.

  8. Colleen Pope Avatar

    Hi Trevor, sounds like we have a similar situation except that it sounds like you’re not having any pain from it anymore, is that right? How much range do you have with your arm and is it always in your sling?
    I wouldn’t be as concerned about my situation if it still didn’t hurt so much….and I do have a high tolerance for pain I think! Being a dirt rider, it is necessary. lol

  9. Trevor Avatar
    Trevor

    I don’t think that you’re being impatient Colleen, that’s just human nature in my book. I have a break which is tenting on my shoulder and surgery is the most likely outcome for my untrained eye. My next appointment is not until the end of Sept and then I’ll have to wait for surgery, if that’s the way the consultant decides upon, and then go through a healing process – it’s all rather depressing isn’t it?
    Cambridgeshire UK.

  10. Colleen Pope Avatar

    Hey, this is my first time on this website…it’s awesome, just discovered it today. Glad I’m not alone in the quest for healing! ๐Ÿ™‚
    I am a 37 year old female who managed to break her left collar bone on August 12th, doing what I love…dirt bike riding.
    My husband had just picked up a brand new Honda CRF450X and wanted to give it a spin. Given the dry, dusty and extremely hot conditions, I wasn’t too keen on going that day, but decided to go for a quick spin. Always one to be safety concious, I wear full protection riding, especially after breaking 2 ribs in my lower back less than a year ago. But all of the safety gear couldn’t help me when I was tossed at high speed to the ground. We were about 2 minutes from the cottage after only a 35km ride. I hit my head on the ground (wearing a helmet of course) so hard that my vision blurred in my left eye for a while. My left shoulder hit pretty hard too and resulted in my collar bone poking out pretty good against my skin. After I managed to get my vision cleared I hopped back on my bike to try to ride the short distance back, but there was too much pain in my left shoulder, so my husband rode back to get our friends to bring the car to get me and he took my dirt bike back. One of my biggest concerns (apart from the head hitting and the protruding bone in my chest) was that I hadn’t had a shower since Friday morning. And you can imagine with all of the dust I rode through while sweating, I was caked with dirt! My girlfriend was kind enough to give me a sponge bath before we proceeded to the hospital. When I went to the hospital, they gave me a figure 8 brace to wear. Apparantly this is the way to go instead of a sling because it wasn’t a clean break and there was fragments. They gave me an Rx for percs and instructions to leave the brace on and go see my own doctor. The problem I had with the figure 8, was that it was cutting off the circulation in my left arm. I’d wake up in the morning (from my upright sleeping position) and couldn’t find the knuckles on my left hand and twisting my arm made my skin hurt. This couldn’t be good. When I saw my doctor, she told me to loosen the brace at night and tighten it during the day, which seemed to work out fine. I had a follow up appointment with her last Thursday (2-1/2 weeks after my accident) and she seemed optomistic that the bone didn’t seem to be tenting as much and I’d have to wear the *$@%^# brace for up to 6 weeks. Up until that morning I was optomistic as well, I went back to work the day before feeling pretty good, except for the unrelenting ache in my whole shoulder. But upon awaking from a restless night, I found much more pain in the bones themselves, almost as if they maybe had started mending and then broke again. My doctor sent me for x-rays and I was unprepared for the results. Anytime I have x-rays done, I always try to get the technician to give me information, but they never do. This time, I didn’t even need to ask, he started asking me if I went to the hospital, which one, did they x-ray me and what did they do for me. This is when I started to get concerned. He asked me to come and look at my x-ray after I got dressed. To my amazement, the bones weren’t even connected…not even close. The bone that is still tenting, is sitting above the other bone and overlapped. By the time my doctor sees my x-rays this week, I will be almost 4 weeks into this and no better off than when it first happened. I’m still taking baths instead of showers. My husband takes my brace off briefly so I can wash my upper body as best I can. I can manage to get T-shirts on, but need help getting them off…tank tops have been the easiest to deal with. After some of the stories I’ve read on this website, people waiting up to 3 months for the bones to heal themselves and then finally having to have surgery just to go through a whole new healing process. This scares me. I am tired of sleeping on my right side with 2 pillows under my head and 1 under my left arm to keep it up. I’m tired of wearing the figure 8 with jackets to hide it in 30 celcius weather (living just north of Toronto, Canada and our summer isn’t over yet!). I want someone to just cut me open and fix it so I can get on with healing and get past this. The only thing this brace seems to be doing is restricting my movement so I don’t do any more damage inside. I definitely don’t feel comfortable without the brace on because I do still feel broken, but I hate the damn thing!
    Am I being too impatient waiting for this thing to heal or am I right to think that if it hasn’t started to mend itself by now, it never will?
    How much damage can be done inside if these bones remain unattached?
    Any comments would be appreciated.

  11. Frank Avatar
    Frank

    Jim
    I have a very hard time believing that anyone in the healthcare field would approve of your son playing soccer so soon. In most cases people normaly survive this break without very serious complications ex; compound fractures(bone comes up through skin) distubances with nerves and a very large artery, take a look at the big picture Jim, it’s only a soccer tournament, your son has a long promising athletic life ahead of him.So why risk a refracture which potentially can be much more serious next time? it’s only one opinion here, but if he was my son, he wouldn’t be playing…..frank

  12. Jen Avatar
    Jen

    Leslie,
    Yes, the fig-8 replaces the sling. It does allow you to use both hands, and I find it to be far more comfortable than the sling ever was. How much you can use your arm and hand is really relative…depends on your bruising, injury, etc. I had significant bruising because I was going so fast at impact, so I have a lot of muscle soreness. And, of course, the idea is to keep the injured area immobilized, so you don’t want to go using that arm/hand too much even when it is freed up.
    I hope you keep healing well!
    Jen

  13. Jim Avatar

    Hi All:
    Would love some advice. My 14 year old son, Nate, broke his collarbone playing ice hockey four weeks ago. He had a central fracture with the tips touching. Incredible pain until the morphine kicked in at which point he became Mr. Happy. He is the strongest player on our soccer team, and we have our semi-finals coming up this weekend, which will be at the five week mark. He has been out of the sling for two weeks, has no pain and is fully mobile. He started fooling around with his hockey stick last weekend.
    The question I have is regarding the relative risk. I am his Dad and his soccer coach. He is the strongest player on the team. He has healed really fast, and at 14 will be at the fastest healing of his life.
    This seems a bit early. Does anyone have any comments on how likely it is that he has actually built up enough strength in the fusion to be safe? How much risk is there if he breaks it again at the same point?
    Any advice appreciated. I am really perplexed as to whether this is just too early.

  14. Leslie A Avatar
    Leslie A

    Everyone:
    This is a HUGE comfort to me. I was just searching the internet for info and found this. I don’t know what you call it (a blog is one person’s diary, right?) but this is awesome!
    My story – 59 year old bike enthusiast (close to 2,000 miles per year). Spinal fusion 5 years ago for scoliosis so pain and restricted activity are no strangers to me.
    Broken left clavical from a fall on Sept 1st. Beginning of group ride. When I got up, I felt the pain immediately on top of the left shoulder. Never felt that kind of pain so soon. So, I knew it wasn’t just soft tissue.
    I’m a dental hygienist so I have some knowledge of medicine and find orthopedics fascinating. Walked my bike back to the start (no, my beautiful custom Seven was not damaged). Fortunately, someone helped me by putting the bike in my car and I drove myself to the ER (10 minutes away). Did I mention I drive a stick shift?!
    Now day 2. I found last night that the pain increases while in the suppine position. Also, the ice helps attenuate the pain even after hour #48.
    Yup, gorgeous weather here in CT. Best of the season. Dry, warm and sunny. Makes it all so much worse.
    I am particularly interested in everyone’s recovery story.
    I have a spinner bike downstairs so it is no problem to use it w/ one hand/arm support.
    Love the tip on getting your own tee shirt on! Luckily my husband is home this week.
    Intrigued by the Figure 8 Brace. DOES THIS REPLACE THE SLING??? So does it allow you to use the arm and to what degree?
    Again, thanks to the originator and other writers.
    United we stand, together we….uh oh – didn’t mean that one!
    Leslie A

  15. MaryAnn Avatar
    MaryAnn

    Well it is just a few days short of 3 weeks from breaking my right collar bone while falling carrying an infant. I HATE this **** figure-8 thingy!!!! At my 2 week checkup I had myself convinced that I would hear wonderful news like no more figure-8! Instead I heard that the original X-RAY taken at the ER was one of the worst clavical breaks my Doc has every seen! Apparently it’s not only broken & overlapping, but also I have several shattered bone pieces in there as well ๐Ÿ™ Doc did say that she was shocked to see me in such great shape & not a ton of pain after seeing my Xray, but that I will probably be in this horrible fig-8 for another 4 to 6 weeks!!!!! I stopped taking the vicidin & ibuprofin after the first week. Has anyone else had the feeling of popcorn popping in there back shoulder & then after a week or so the feeling of bugs running all around inside your shoulder & up & down your arm at odd intervals & a burning sensation a lot? I can actually see the skin twitching & a bubbling kind of motion in my arm at times too.Thankyou in advance for any replies:) MaryAnn

  16. Trevor Avatar
    Trevor

    Hi
    Thanks for the reply Elly. I think he would have gone down the surgery route but because I was not keen and have not got full movement in that shoulder anyway, I think he was prepared to wait. All I was given for support was a velcro fastening arm sling. I don’t think that the NHS is big on flashy supports? I don’t know how a non-union affects the shoulder in the long run but the x-ray did show a distance between fractures & that displacement may be a big problem, together with the tented skin? I’ll just have to play it by ear for a while I assume.
    I know I shouldn’t be perhaps, but I’m always trusting that consultants know what they are doing and I feel out of my depth to question them!
    Trevor

  17. Elly Avatar
    Elly

    Hi Trevor,
    If the doctor said surgery was not needed, then you probably wouldn’t need pins or plates. However, you can always get a second opinion.
    Just keep in mind that in most cases clavicle fractures heal on their own but you still need a figure-8 support (in my case it was a universal support which immobilized the shoulder, kept the elbow next to my body and fixed my wrist to the front of a kind of belt enfording my waist).
    Good luck and quick healing!

  18. Trevor Avatar
    Trevor

    Hi All
    I fell off my pushbike on Aug 23 and broke my left clavicle. The bone is tenting (not breaking) the skin and it doesn’t look great. I went to clinic yesterday and the registrar said surgery would be needed. The consultant was called and he suggested waiting a month to see what happens. I am not in pain and only have limited use in that arm & hand anyway due to residual paralysis from head injuries received in a previous motorcycle RTA. The consultant said that I didn’t meet the criteria for urgent surgery so thought it best to wait. I’m not sure how it will go but think that if I want pre-injury appearance, movement & strength then I’ll have to have it pinned or whatever they do these days?
    Cambridgeshire, UK

  19. John Vander Wyden Avatar

    I broke my clavicle and 8 ribs front and back on my right side.
    This was on July 12th, 50 days ago. I am feeling great compared to how I felt right after the accident. The clavicle and 2 of the ribs still bother me. I have a disk that the imaging facility gave me with my X-Rays and MRI images. I am now waiting for the orthopedic doctor to tell me if my body is laying down a fibrous bridge and healing. My X-rays really scared me when I first saw them because the two peices of the clavicle seem so far apart, sort of hanging over each other. The doctor allayed my fears and explained how that was common. The injury itself is very common in cycling and motor cross.
    How is your shoulder coming along, and long term effects. It’s been a while now hasnt it?

  20. Jen Avatar
    Jen

    Bummer! The front-closing brace arrived, and it’s not going to work. The straps are stiff and cannot possibly be worn comfortably under one’s arms; you’d have to hold them straight out, like a stick person. It also creates downward pressure on the clavicle, which obvoiusly is not a good thing. It comes with a very thick, rounded foam insert that is supposed to go between your shoulder blades, which makes sitting back in a chair or lying down impossible. It is removable, but then the support doesn’t work correctly. All in all, poor design for our needs. I would not recommend it.
    Guess it’s back to the figure-8 for support, but remaining dependent on my friends’ help. ๐Ÿ™

    Thanks for posting your review. Maybe I should add a review section for shoulder supports? Or maybe it’s time for someone to invent a comfortable and usable shoulder support!

    Glad you got good news, Frank!

  21. kharen hill Avatar
    kharen hill

    just a couple of comments…I have been sleeping in a “zero gravity” (outside chair from Costco or canadian tire) chair that swings flat and also upright. You can’t roll over and hurt your shoulder. Also the codine they gave me at emergency made me dizzy, nautious so I stopped taking it. The doctors didn’t mention that could be a side effect.
    I don’t know why any-one would be trying to madly exercise in the first couple of weeks. I am at day 8 and my briuses are not completely heled and neither are my other aches and pains, so I think it is better to give your body a break and try and let it heal without pushing it?

  22. Frank Avatar
    Frank

    Hey Jen….How’s that clavicle healing? Congradulations on finding a front fastening figure 8 brace, I could have used one, and it’s good that the people reading this forum know there out there…Things are healing well here, in fact I seen another Doctor and he assured me that my clavicle is healing, without having to look at an xray…I’ve been getting positive vibes about laying on my left side…so I did..and that was fine, never hurt!! I won’t sleep on it though, I’ll wait another couple of weeks for that…good to hear you have that poison ivy thing overwith, like you needed that on top of everything!!….take care…and good healing to all……

  23. Allison - Jersey, Channel Islands Avatar
    Allison – Jersey, Channel Islands

    Hi there, this site has been really informative and helpful. I broke my collar bone some 13 weeks ago. I have had two lots of x-rays which apparently reveal that the break has resulted in the bones crossing over and I have a rather large lump. The consultant told me that the x-rays reveal that there has been no change in the bones since the fracture in May. I am due to have more x-rays in October. I have a virtually full range of movement. I’m not particularly worried about the bump though and the pain had subsided considerably. However, two days ago the pain returned and I developed tingling in my hand and a loss of strength in my fingers resulting in me not being able to successfully use a spray can or write properly….i know that when i first went to hospital I was asked if I had pins & needles which I did not and i am somewhat alarmed that this has developed over 3 months later…has anybody else experienced similar? I am a 43 year old female..

    What you describe might be caused by a nerve being impinged. I would recommend that you follow up with your doctor and describe your new condition.

  24. Jen Avatar
    Jen

    Thanks for the tip on side sleeping. I was worried that the weight shift would move my left shoulder down in a bad way since the bone is definitely not bridged yet, but I’ll give it a try.
    I’m not too worried about how I look, so the bruising, etc. isn’t too big a deal. The poison ivy was the gross part, and that has finally just about healed, thank goodness! It’s a little weird to get stared at whenever I go out, but kind of funny, too.

    Speaking of the evil poison oak, I have a few pages of info with my experiences with that nasty plant:

    http://www.hanskellner.com/archives/2003/01/14/poison_oak_argh.html

    I hope I found just what I need: a front-closing brace. I ordered it tonight, and really, really hope that I can take it on and off myself while still getting enough support. I’m having a hard time not being able to adjust it at night, etc. when a friend is not around to help me, and I don’t want to keep depending on them for the next 6 weeks (even though they are wonderful about it)!
    http://www.dme-direct.com/royce-medical-front-closure-clavicle-support/
    Have any of you ever used this product?
    I hope you continue to heal well, Frank!

  25. Frank Avatar
    Frank

    As I read your story Jen, I found alot of simularities to mine, even my ortho broke his collar bone. I came on to update my progress which started on june 23rd, my last posting was August 11th, but just to comment on a couple of things you talked about Jen, the figure of 8, the jury’s out on that one, I personally liked it and thought it was doing me some good, but being single I had to trash it. Hopefully when NASA is done with the space station, they can help engineer one that fastens at the front…The bruising, expect that to be hanging around for a while, I’m at 8 weeks and it’s finally left me, yes it can be hard on ya if your attached to physical appearance. My left wing looked like it belonged to” Mongomery Burns” (the simpsons….google him, you said you don’t watch any TV) my delts, bicep and tricep basically disappeared and the pain was awful. But I can say that it’s all much better now, until I look at an xray of course. On the 20th I went for my 8 week xray….no change, same picture as before. It’s funny how you can feel so well, confident, and strong and then look at a picture and feel so deflated. But it was only a brief moment, it’s only 8 weeks to early to see new bone and theres definately some bone knitting happening despite what the x ray shows, my own intellegence is telling me that things are healing fine, and thats what I’m going by, not an xray. My ortho wants me back in 6 weeks and gives me a 50/50 chance of having union, I had him place his fingers over the fracture site to feel the strength in it (which doesn’t back up the xray) but he fails to comment, he says I’m tough!!.I do like the guy though he is a good ortho/surgeon,and he’s not pushing me for a plate, in fact he say’s, thats all going to depend on me, how I’m feeling and whether I want it. I joke with him and tell him I feel great when I’m not looking at xrays..for those of you at this stage, I don’t want to sound cynical, but there are some differing opinons out there about the reliability of xrays to show new growth. if you can find it some where in this forum, there was a guy by the name of Jeff Brook read his story and follow ups, its awhile ago, but interesting. He like myself was having xrays show up negative on healing. But like me, he was very active and was concerned of his life ahead without a healed clavicle. His surgeon told him that although the xrays and ct scans show new bone, it doesn’t always mean theres none there, he told jeff that he once opened a guy up under the same circumstances as his, only to find bone!!! and I believe it, thats probably a stat thats not recorded or ever talked about. Having said that, there are cases for surgery, and plenty of success stories there as well….Iguess the only thing that bites for me now is that I still can’t begin to strength train, despite that I’m feeling darn good, I can lift 30 pounds with the left no problem, but some of the differnt ranges and arm positions still hurt (without weight)…back to you Jen, if your able to sleep on your right side that might help the strap burn on back..lol..I was suprised to read you were out at a concert after a week with no pain, Iwas still doing perkies at that point, I was getting out, but a little wired up.You’ll have your ups and downs, but it sounds like your healing faster than i was..and I hope things continue to go well for you, take care and fast healing to all….frank

  26. Jen Avatar
    Jen

    Hello all!
    Wow, reading these stories has done me a world of good. I broke my left clavicle on Aug 12 coming down a speedy downhill on my trusty Cannondale F600 and skidding out on some loose dirt on the tight curve at the bottom. I landed directly on my left shoulder, bounced over once on my head (thank you, helmet!) and have some impressive road rash on my left shoulder blade that is just starting to heal.
    The only person in my group with any first aid training was, well, me! (My buddy’s girlfriend is a doctor; I said, “Do you know what to do?” She said, “No.”) Somehow I remained completely calm and gave directions until the emergency team showed up to drive me out on an ATV. I thought I could walk out, but shock was setting in and I couldn’t walk more than 2 steps without almost passing out. I remember telling my friends, “Lay me down. Now elevate my feet. Someone give me water.” I will eventually forgive my friend who, meaning to help, poured purple Gatorade in my eyes while trying for my mouth. Thank goodness for the training I received on my NOLS Outdoor Educator course in WY this June! The only critical mistake I made was lying down in a patch of poison ivy. So road rash on the left shoulder blade, oozing sores on the right blade–it’s quite sexy, really.
    The emergency team was quite enthusiastic, but a little Keystone Cops scene played out: the oxygen mask was partly over my eyes, so I had a wind blowing directly onto my eyes until I got them to move it down over my nose/face; the women taking my vitals kept unpacking a bag and bumping me really hard every time she did so; they poked me four times in four places in my right arm(and each one is now a purple bruised knot) in order to start a morphine IV, which they eventually had to do in my left arm which I was clutching to my chest for dear life. “You want me to straighten it?” was all I could say in disbelief, but straighten I did; needed the morphine just for that; the man leaning over me in the ATV was sweating copiously onto my face, so I had his sweat stinging my eyes; they couldn’t get the stretcher to lock in place in the ambulance and began slamming it hard until I yelled, “I’m on this thing!” to which they replied, “Sh*t! We forgot!”.
    After all that, the ER folks gave me more good drugs, took some x-rays and sent me home with a sling that was made for Andre the Giant (I am 5′ 7″ and 130) and a script for Percocet. I’d asked for Vicodin, but they talked me into Percs which made me puke. After two days with that nuisance, the Ortho I saw was incredibly helpful–my condolances to all of you who had to deal w/ Ortho’s with poor or indifferent bedside manner. He’d had a broken collarbone himself and said that while current research says the sling is the way to go, the figure-8 is what worked for him. He rigged me up and sent me home with Vicodin. Aahhh! Now I could sleep and find some comfort.
    So here I am, 8 days into recovery, and was surprised to find myself in good enough shape to go to a Crowded House concert a couple of days ago, and on a date yesterday. I am not taking anything for pain. The only trouble I have is with the lump the straps the figure-8 makes right on my spine when I sleep; it’s gettng a bit sore. Any tips for that? I’m also having those fiery pains and numbness many of you have described, depending on my arm position. I know it’s nerve-related, and I’m hoping it goes away soon as things continue to heal. I just got the neon-yellow bruising creeping down my torso thing some of you have had, and that is further helping the sexy look. ๐Ÿ™‚
    This has been an exercise in patience and dependence. For example, it iss challenging to feel both grateful to and irritated with my ex-boyfriend who helped me shower that first night to get the dirt out of my back. He was incredibly helpful, but keeps calling to see if I need another shower. Uh, no.
    Like many of you, I’m used to being incredibly active (rock climber, mtn biker, whitewater kayaker), so this is tough. I’ve gotten incredibly adept at being one-handed, even typing, and I’m grateful that it’s summer so I can slip into strappy tank tops with ease after I pull them up over my hips. It’s also been raining for almost a week, so I don’t feel I’m missing too much!
    Today was kind of a low day emotionally. I am bored, tired of needing help with the brace, not being able to do certain things for myself. I’m not a tv watcher, but my friends set me up with a set and a dvd player, so I’ve watched a ton of movies. It helps, but the charm is fading. Reading, doing some work (which is mostly by email, fortunately), helps and friends visit, but yeah–there are times I struggle. I try to remind myself that at least I am alive, and I could have injured far more severely, so I’m lucky. It helps (as does the occasional single malt scotch…!).
    I am glad there’s such a cool, prestigious club of which I am now a member, and I thank you for your stories. You’ve cheered me up on a gloomy evening. It’s also good to have a realistic picture of the time I will take to heal, being 36. I’m resting mostly to work with my body instead of against it, and we’ll see how long I take… Thanks, everyone!
    Missing my bike (she rolled away without a scratch, at least),
    Jen

  27. MaryAnn Avatar
    MaryAnn

    Well I must say my broken collar bone story is rather unique when compared to the others I’ve read here! I am not a youngster by any stretch of the means & I would TOTALLY not consider myself an athlete, unless of course having five children – ranging in age of 27, 25(today), 14, 7,& 4 qualify me! LOL I am a 48 year old, 1st time grandma ๐Ÿ™‚ Yes, my lovely 27 year old daughter gave birth to my very first grandchild 6 weeks ago. And that is how I broke my collar bone!! I was simply walking down the street with my daughter as I carried my wonderful new grandbaby in my loving arms with loads of graceful pride. OK maybe not so graceful – I somehow managed to twist myself up and land smack on my back, banging my, ankle, knee, & head on the way down to the hard pavement. My only thoughts were making sure the baby did not get hurt, so I clutched him close to my breasts and threw myself backwards when I realized I had lost my balance. Happy to report the baby came out without anything more than a supersized squeeze from Grandma! One moment I was feeling like a vibrant young mother of a 4 year old & the next I was an old wounded Grandma sprawled out on the pavement! My dauhgter grabbed her baby from my chest & loosened grip from the impacked & gasped with relief that he was OK. I myself caught my breath & thanked God for his safe landing. Then I proceeded to sit up & attempt my stance to the erect world. The minute I rose to my feet I felt the creepy snap-crackle-pops and could not understand how I may have managed to break my right arm! But it sure felt like I had. We continued on our way only to make it a few more steps before I told my daughter something wasn’t quite right & I thought I needed medical attention. She agreed with a horrified gasp when I exposed the huge bump protruding from my right collar bone. (I am also right handed) This was 9:00PM on Tuesday, (my wedding anniversary was the next day) I was back home from the ER and sitting on my potty, pucking my gutts out onto the floor by 4:00AM I am in a T-back shoulder brace & an arm sling. My advice here is EAT something with each dose of the ibeprofin. Thank God for Vicidin & a great hubby & a couple of great kids to wait on me cause I am feeling rather useless & helpless!!!! And that is my story & I am sticking to it!

  28. Anna Avatar
    Anna

    Margaux —
    I was so sorry to read of your plight. Since your injury happened on the job, can’t your employer help out at all? I’m not a lawyer, but I would imagine that even if someone was just visiting the work place and was injured there would be some liability involved.
    Best wishes,
    Anna

  29. nikki Avatar
    nikki

    i am so glad i found this site it has been great to know im not the only like this i am on my 7week of a broken collar bone i was out for the first time in months and when i fell i was in a club and they were haveing a foam party and yes i fell in it i didnt know i had broke my collar to i had to go to hosiptal were i got an xray i still cant lift my arm up above my head i got my xray last week and no healing but the doc told me it can take up to 3months to fully heal so here is hopeing

  30. Elly Avatar
    Elly

    Thanks Frank!
    I guess I just needed someone to tell me s/he felt just as bad at some point. This is because I thought I would be as good as new once I had the pins out. Then I decided the clavicle might break again if I did anything drastic…
    Actually, my doctor told me to move the arm without raising it up over my head, or at least that’s what he demonstrated I should not do. I am thinking of trying finger walking up the wall, though, and listening to my body. ๐Ÿ˜‰
    Maybe I should also pester the doctor some more when I go to have the two stitches taken out.

  31. Frank Avatar
    Frank

    Elly
    I just googled….”shoulder rehab” and theres plenty of good information and shoulder exercises there.My range of motion was very limited as well and when I went for my 4 week follow up my ortho had me raise it up over my head which I never thought it would do, and I never would have attempted that on my own without his consent or him standing rate there watching me.If i were you at this point I would ask your doctor to be a little more specific on what exercises to do. Maybe he did tell you to start raising your arm above your head, and if thats the case, start finger walking up the wall, you have to put up with alot of discomfort in the beginning Elly, but it gets alot better, listen to your own body intellegence as well, when you feel you should stop exercising and rest it..Then obey that feeling.

  32. Elly Avatar
    Elly

    Hello to all members of the Broken Clavicle Club! Many thanks to Hans for founding it!
    This site was a mine of information and reassurance that I was not alone and if others could do, then I could do it, too. ๐Ÿ™‚
    And here is my small contribution:
    It all began on June 24, 2007. I wish it had been triggered by a mountain bike, football or any other kind of exciting activity.
    However, on the above date, I was simply watering the garden when I slipped, fell with my right hand stretched and ended up with a distal clavicle fracture close to the acromioclavicular joint.
    Faced with the choice of wearing a figure-8 brace which, I was told, will only show non-union in 20 days or having two pins inserted which will speed up the healing process, I went for the surgery. The next day I was scheduled, had general anesthesia and woke up with some extra metal inside me.
    The following weeks are familiar to everyone on this site so I won’t delve into them. What I hadn’t realized at the time was that the pins, which were curved at the end, could rotate inside me. At the end of the second week, one of the pins performed exactly that, slowly but thoroughly. This meant excruciating pain and heavy doses of ibuprofen. The other pin also found a new place and almost pierced the skin, but luckily it did not rotate.
    At the end of the 6th week, the orthopedist extracted the pins with local anesthesia and told me to begin moving my arm and shoulder without lifting anything heavy and without making sudden movements.
    The problem is that after being immobilized for 6 weeks

  33. Nadav Avatar
    Nadav

    Hey how you guys doin’? well, I ain’t doing good. I broke my collarbone 1.5 years ago while playing basketball in school, I was 15.5 years of age, Now I just celebrated my 17th birthday.
    I live in Israel so if my english is lacking then i’m sorry :/
    I broke my left collarbone when a player collided directly into my clavicle, I head my collarbone snap into half, Well, something snapped into half, didn’t know what exactly…
    My mom picked me up and took me to the hospital, I don’t remember doing xrays, I just remember that the doctor brutally took my shirt off and glanced at my bone and confirmed that it was indeed a collarbone fracture, the bone snapped into half.
    I remember not seeing the collarbone, it wasn’t visible.. like I didn’t have a collarbone, what does it mean? I had a massive dislocation of the bone?
    anyway, as of today the bones are overlapping by 2 cms and my left collarbone is visibly shoter than the right side, My dominant side is right by the way.
    I didn’t do physiotherapy, because I was insructed by the doctor.
    Today, I really care about my cosmetics, Is there an option that my chest muscle has changed because of the shortenning of the clavical? it is different than the right side.
    I’m leanning towards surgery, but the doctors I went to don’t wanna operate, and if one does agree, is it different from the stage when the bones hasn’t fused yet? will I have to make a bone graft? and will my collarbone be the same as my right side? I mean cosmetical.
    and will the shave my bone just like the right side? because the left collarbone is thicker and doesn’t have an anatomcial look,it’s straight.
    Last question, is it a complciated surgery? because the bones are already fused…
    thanks for any help, Nadav.

  34. Frank Avatar
    Frank

    Frank again!…Forgot to attach the link on fracture healing…My opinions above are also the opinions of many in the medical field, Here is the one link I had saved, there are many other articles like this around…Google…fracture healing… cheers http://www.e-radiography.net/radpath/f/fracture.htm

  35. Frank Avatar
    Frank

    My membership into the very large “fractured clavicle” club began on June 23rd, 7 weeks ago tonight, like many of the other stories it happened on a mountain bike, racing downhill with a friend who tried to pass me and nudged my handle bars..all I remember from that point is my head collecting gravel through the vents on my helmet,. and the weight of the world resting on my left shoulder..It’s a good thing it was a cold evening and I was wearing a thick fleece cause the rash would have been to the bone!! I’ve waited this long to write only because it would be more value to others reading who have just recently hurt themselves..This may look long but I can assure you it will put your mind at ease..the first set of x-rays showed a single clean break 3 quarters of the way down my collar bone towards my shoulder I also fractured 2 ribs and puntured my left lung which didnt require any surgery. I noticed while looking at my x-ray (and this has importance later on) that the clavicle at the fracture site was slightly overlapped with very little displacement. The shoulder joint looked fine,but it was obvious in the days that followed, that it suffered a very bad sprain. Home I went wired on morphine and a perscription for percaset, thank god for that!! The first 4 weeks had it’s ups and downs, I managed to get the left arm far enough away from my body to get a bar of soap under it while in the shower.I watched 4 seasons of the Saprano,s and did plenty of web brousing. An overwhelming amount of information that I read on the internet was VERY positive, all the well respected sports injury and medical institutions around North America were in agreement that non union was rare and corrective surgery was reserved for the few who suffered serious complications ex: compound fractures”thats when the bone penetrates through the skin; fracture sites around the base of the neck which could interfere with a large artery and nerves; and severe dislocations which is characterized by extreme tenting of the skin. This site was very positive and supportive as well, but I became aware of the needless worry and anxiety that many suffered from the “worst case senerios” given by there doctors. Iam in no way trying to undermine doctors and surgeons here, and for the unfortunate few thank god we have them, but the rest of my story will get you thinking in a positive way,which is most important with any type of recovery.
    I have to be honest and say that for a short while I became concerned about the implications of non union, but I would run my fingers over the fracture site and I could feel one end of the collarbone, and rate underneath it (with no space between) was the other piece which came from my shoulder. At 4 and a half weeks it was not tender or painfull to touch,but if I performed any movement with my arm that put stress at the fracture site I felt a pinch ( the shockers comming read on) Off I go for my 4 week follow up, an xray is taken and then the wait for the ortho surgeon and I’m feeling pretty confident here, in he walks and I say..feels like I have some union happening here, and he says what are ya from another planet no-body heals that quick (fair comment) then he says I’ll show you your xray shortly, let me see how much arm movement you have, which wasn’t much and he wasn’t happy with that(much better now though!) then I looked at the x ray and I couldn’t believe my eyes, the fracture looked displaced by at least a half inch.Definately not what I was feeling. Then he says I was hoping to see signs of healing happening between the bones,so I want you to come back in 4 weeks and if thers still no sign we’ll have to start thinking of putting a plate in there..Yikes!!
    There I go back home worried and doubting my own intellegence of whats really happening in my body..First I want to say, before I had that x-ray I repeatedly moved that arm and shoulder around while feeling the overlapped clavicle and the 2 bones NEVER moved apart from one another, I felt those bones often and they were never apart,not after week 3 anyway. My important point is, be very carefull what you read into x rays,they don’t always give an accurate picture especially when it comes to displacement, your displacement could be much smaller then it appears, you don’t have to have overlap for healing, it bridges well even with large gaps, and something else, I’m attaching a web page (in case you haven’t seen it) that explains the bone healing process..theres 2 types of union first is clinical which depending on your age can take 4-6 weeks, its discribed as a fibrous callous that first forms between your bones, this formation can pass undetected by x-rays. then theres radiograph union, that is the stage in which the bone begins to calcify, and again this stage can also take 4-6 weeks depending on age. That means it can take anywhere from 8-12 weeks before you see any new bone on x-rays, and seeing that I’m 43 I should be at the higher end..I f your worried about union..look at your road rash, is it healing? In my opinion when your road rash is scarred over (no more scabs) you have clinical union inside, and don’t be disappointed if your x rays show no new bone growth. I just wish all doctors can get on the same page with this.My next appointment is in a week and I’ll give ya’s a report. Ican tell you for sure that if I dont see any new calcium I won’t panic cause it will only be 8 and a half weeks,other than that I’m starting to feel just great, big improvements after week 4,physio is going well, don’t worry you’ll get your arm moving again. Happy healing and I hope you found this comforting…..Frank

  36. Margaux Avatar
    Margaux

    Hello anyone who can help!
    I work for a very small but extremely promising company that (sigh) has no health insurance policy. One of my co-workers accidentally knocked me down while on the job, and because of how I fell….my clavical broke near the top of my left shoulder.(im a contracted employee so no insurance will cover)
    I had to go to the doc in Akron ohio so Im pretty sure they are not the authority on collar bone breakage. Only thing is that I just graduated from college and have no health insurance (nor family(foster child)/relatives/kind un-homeless neighbors) to speak of. they put me in a sling but i think that I need a brace that pulls my shoulder/clavical back into place like the figure-8 braces I have been told about.
    Im so confused and I cant afford to go to an ortho doc. I am dying to run/workout because its my refuge, but I have no idea how far I can push this without permanent injury. I am so tired of camping out in the university library in order to use the computers…. please help!
    any suggestions? Im broke. Im begging. Im desperate. Im
    out of options as well as left arms. my boss (and my only source of income)will not accept “excuses”….
    thank you!
    margaux

  37. Tom Avatar
    Tom

    Hello Hans
    I have been fascinated by the stories and tips on your site.
    I came off my motorbike on a sharp left hand bend at 7.15 pm on Tuesday, 31 July (probably caused by a patch of diesel fuel). One second I was on, next I was sliding across the road. I was only two miles away from home, having spent a great afternoon biking in the glorious Peak District.
    Severe pain in left shoulder and inability to get up told me I had probably broken my collar bone.
    Am very lucky to be alive since a car was coming the other way, fortunately being driven sensibly. The young woman driver called an ambulance and then my wife. My leathers saved my skin and my crash helmet saved my life.
    At very busy hospital the doctor confirmed that I had a multiple fracture and a nurse put my arm in a simple sling and sent me home at 11 pm with appointment for fractures clinic two days later on August 2. I was in a lot of pain and I could feel bones moving around – I tried to sleep in an armchair with a worried wife on settee opposite.
    However, I read on the ‘net that most fractures heal normally with sling, and so the following day (Wednesday) I honoured my promise to video my grandaughter’s birthday party. Pain continued to get worse…
    On Thursday morning – after hardly any sleep – I realized why when I saw the X-Ray in the fractures clinic: my collar bone was broken in three places with a two – three inch floating piece in the middle. No wonder I had felt it moving about!
    The surgeon told me that he normally only saw this sort of injury in 35 year olds (I am 62). Not sure how to interpret this…
    However, he suggested that since I was obviously active (I go to the gym three times a week) he would fix it together with a titanium plate, hopefully the following day (Friday, August 3).
    Incidentally he told me that this had to be done within 7 – 10 days of the break – I have not seen any other reference to this time restriction on your site.
    Arriving at hospital next morning (in even more pain) I was delighted to hear that he had scheduled me as the first operation of the day. When I came to, now wearing a proper sling, I felt comfortable for the first time since the accident but was very grateful later that day for the repeated doses of morphine to deal with the pain – worst in the middle of the night – but recovered well enough to be discharged after one night in hospital.
    A physiotherapist gave me exercises: pendulum swings of the shoulder, wrist rotations, bicep curls and shoulder shrugs!!!
    I am delighted to say that the pain has gradually subsided and I have now stopped taking pain killers during the day. Am scheduled to see the surgeon again next week.
    My biggest problem now is reduced mobility and sleeping propped up on pillows.
    As everyone on your site has said the simplest things become difficult or impossible: I can manage dressing, washing with a flannel and shaving, and am keeping the very moist area under left armpit under control with anti-bacterial gel. However, I am finding it nearly impossible to put my socks on!
    Am also under a lot of pressure to give up motorcycling and my bike: a BMW R100RS which is now waiting to have the damage repaired. This is despite the fact that this is my only accident in the twenty years since I returned to motorcycling…
    I do feel bad, however, since one of my daughters, who is over eight months pregnant, told me she thought she was going into labour when she saw me lying at the side of the road with my face as white as a sheet. Apparently the young lady who called my wife said “I am very sorry to have to inform you that your husband…” Result: a very worried wife, two distressed daughters, son-in-law and daughter’s boyfriend all rushed out to scene of accident!
    Please keep up the good work on your site – it really helps to read about other people’s experiences with this painful injury.
    Tom

  38. makena Avatar
    makena

    Update from makena: I finally got a second opinion. My first ortho guy said, “oh, it just takes time to heal, be patient” This is after I looked at the same x-ray he did and don’t see my bones “fusing” at all. They were overlapping but not healing together. He said, it just takes time.
    I went to another doctor after waiting 8 weeks with the first dr. the new guy’s first look at the x-ray, he said, “your bones aren’t fusing. we call that “non-union”. You need surgery.”
    Just had surgery last tuesday, july 31. I now have a straight bone with a bone graft in the middle. a seven inch rod and 7 screws in it. alot of pain still, but that was aggravated by the fact that by waiting 8 weeks, scar tissue had formed and they had to scrape that out.
    My advice, if you don’t like what you’re hearing or seeing, get a second opinion, sooner!

  39. Raz Avatar
    Raz

    Hans this is a great site for those of us dealing with our clavicle injuries. I found your site a few weeks ago and read your story, and returned today and read Laura’s, as well as a few of the other postings on the site. Some entertaining stories and I find encouragment with the reading.
    I broke my clavicle and a rib while cornering one of the switchbacks on Squaw Pass in Colorado on June 24th. I think that I hit some gravel and then lost control, though I really only remember the sound of the wheels coming out from under me and the next thing a stopping motorist asking if I was okay? Well, at first I thought I was ok and that I would be finishing my ride but I couldn’t really move much…really had the wind knocked out of me! Eventually I did get up and a lady that had stopped, who is a nurse, immediately told me that I had a broken clavicle. She and her husband were kind enough to load my bike in their truck and drive me to an Urgent Care in Evergreen. The urgent care xrayd and treated the break and road rash….probably a 3-4 hr visit. I have followed up with my family physician as well as an orthopedic. Both say I will get back to normal…although I’ve been pretty frustrated with my range of motion. I guess at 46 I’m not going to bounce back like a 25-year old!
    Well, here is the weird part; just over 1-week ago I was taken to the ER and admitted to the hospital for a Transient Ischemic Attack (TIA). Until last week I had never heard of a TIA, which the doctor explained to be a mini-stroke. First, i can’t believe anything like this would happen to me…I’ve been very fit and active my entire life! The docs put me through more tests than I like to admit with all my results being normal. With the exception of two things, the MRI showed I also have a broken rib (from the bike accident, which none of the other doctors I had seen managed to tell me about); the echocardiogram showed a PFO (small hole in my heart). The PFO has been with me all of my life and I understand that about 20-25% of the population has this condition. However, the TIA scared the crap out of me!The doctors don’t seem to think that the TIA had anything to do with the bike accident, but in my opinion it’s just too much of a coincidence. My cholestrol levels are good, blood pressure normally around 118/70…never a health concern in my life. Now I crash my bike and have a TIA a month later! My thoughts are that maybe I had a small blood clot from the crash that made it’s way to my brain through the PVO and shut some things down for a while (I felt back to normal within about 60-90 minutes). I’ll be seeing neurologists whenever I can find one that can get me in. I suppose if the docs felt it was all that serious I would be seeing a neorologist at the ER.
    Sorry for the long post, I’ve been pretty consummed with this. I have a wife and 2 small kids that are as freaked out by this as I am. Hoping for some answers!

  40. bill (from b4) Avatar
    bill (from b4)

    Hi i posted an article about a month ago, im almost at week six and feeling prety good. To the article above, the world is a two handed world. Unless you use one arm ur whole life, you wont be used to it. Anyway i had a couple questions, im not in great shape becuz of all this rest but i dont wanna start doing weights becuz i dont know if my bone is really healed or just mended. My mom said she would take me for an x-ray at the walk in clinic but they take about 1-2 weeks and get sent to my family doctor. Im 16, how long do guys my age usually wait b4 doing weights or sit-ups, runnning? Does it really take 3 months minimum b4 ur bones as strong as b4? I just dont wanna be the person who rebreaks their collarbone. I would appreciate the advice becuz no other site has a good forum like this one.

  41. Charles Avatar
    Charles

    Wow…welcome to my life. You ought to try this: ball your dominant hand in a fist and wrap it with sports tape. Live like that for a week. Buttons, tight pants, etc., all of that works fine. Bras? Pssh…I can undo a girl’s bra quicker than she can herself using two fingers. Buttons four or five. Use your pinky, ring, and thumb to hold the hole side and the two remaining fingers to pull on the button of your pants. Once aligned, reposition your thumb so that you are pinching together both sides of the waistband. The rest is easy. Tying shoes is a breeze, too. I also play tennis and guitar. I’m sorry to say, but that article is quite laughable. A two-handed world? Yeah, right.

  42. dave Avatar

    my hobbies are triathlon and golf.
    its impossible to compare injuries.
    this is what i know.
    doctors say my break is “acute” with some
    overlap.
    i crashed onto my left side (to avoid a dog)
    while cycling at 15-mph.
    a blow to my elbow broke the clavicle.
    i passed-out for 20-seconds.
    i am depressed::
    honestly, what should i expect about
    making “normal/hard” golf swings again?
    what about the “free-style” swimming motion?
    am i screwed?
    honestly, is triathlon over for me?
    after 5 days i have very little motion,
    and can lift only very light objects, in
    the shoulder that is “not” broken.
    thanks.
    -dw
    btw: i don’t remember the accident, however the dog is in
    good health. i must have missed the dog, elsewise it would
    be a dead dog.
    aren’t there leash laws????

  43. Frank Avatar
    Frank

    Hans
    I want to thank you for all the useful information on the sight. I,ll be disclosing my story and helpful hint,s in time. But for know I have a question that I hope you can answer. How did Laura Erker,s story ever finish? My injury and progress was almost a mirror image of hers, and her last report was heading out the door for x rays at 8 wks and then nothing after that? Did she find union?
    regards Frank

    Good question! I’ll see if I can get some info from her.

  44. Anthony Avatar
    Anthony

    Great news today!! I’ve been for my week 9 x-ray and the consultant said that the bone had ‘fully united’. What a relief. I know I’ve still got to be very careful not to do too much too soon and put myself back to square 1, but it’s so nice to get some positive news. Maybe now that will increase my positive thoughts and speed my full recovery. Hans, thanks for running this site and giving people who are completely fed up somewhere to air there frustrations and hopefully help towards the healing process

  45. AB Avatar
    AB

    I first hurt mine in August of 2005 during Football practice, and I still played on it not knowing until I got X-Rays after the season in November and got the results back in December before Christmas.And till this day it still hurts and my bone sticks out. To make things worst I have my senior season coming up.

  46. James Avatar
    James

    My adventure which broke my right clavicle at age 46
    To Much Fun In The Sun.
    The day is Sunday May 27th I awoke to a message on my answering machine from my best friend inviting me and my other half to a cookout. I called and confirmed we would both be there and sure enough we showed up.
    We arrived around 1pm and joined the party. During the cookout I had nine beers and made sure I ate well.
    We played bat mitten and before we knew it the sun was setting and so we went inside to play darts. My other half wanted to head home around ten pm and so I got her in the car and brought her home “once there I asked if she would mind if I went back to the cookout for a couple of hours and she said sure if you want to. Well rather than
    Take the car back since it was such a nice night I grabbed my motorcycle helmet and took my Honda Nighthawk instead. I stayed a few hours and had a few more beers. I asked my friend Chris (who was also there)
    If he wanted a ride home and he said sure so off we went. I dropped him off (about four miles from my place) and headed home. I was about seventy yards from my place at a stop sign when I blacked out. I did not feel intoxicated or dizzy. I did not see this coming at all. I do not even recall getting up let alone slamming the pavement. I recall swearing at the bike and seeing two guys walking up the side street and yelling for help. They up righted the bike quickly and I rode it home. Once home I could tell I had hurt
    my right shoulder. I went inside after parking the bike and then went in the bathroom to see the shoulder in the mirror and I could see the bone sticking up. I asked my other half if she wanted to go to the hospital to have a blood test her doctor requested and she of course replied are you nuts in ONE AM in the morning. I said well you mind as well since I have to go and she asked why so I showed he the bone. She went nuts. She was going to call 911 and I said no lets get in the car I will drive “‘since she can not drive. Once in the car I went into shock and we made our way back inside and she called 911. She told 911 I fell off my bike so the cops also showed up. Needless to say I lied and told them I was moving the bike in its parking space and going to cover it up for two days of rain coming. They tried to get my other half to confess I was riding and she kept her smarts and said I was home all night. Then they went to look at the bike. Since the bike got very little damage they figured it only fell over and left.
    Off to the hospital via ambulance.
    Once there I knew I had to state the same as told to the police. The hospital staff did not draw blood and only took x-rays and eventually told me I broke my collar bone and put me in a figure eight brace and a sling and gave me a prescription for oxycodone/apap
    After fours hours it was time to hail a cab and head home.
    I was quick to contact a bone specialist who also turns out to be a surgeon. His name is Ken. Ken points out I got a very bad break that may heal on its own in six months “however he can operate and pull the bone back into place with an L shape piece of metal and a few screws. He says doing so should bring the healing time down to five or six weeks. So I agree.
    Surgery day arrives June 12th
    I come out of the Anastasia only to learn the operation that was supposed to take about one hour took over two hours and that rather than the L shaped metal I got a full length of the collar bone metal and seven screws. Ken said the bone splintered. For some reason he did not see this on the x-rays.
    Regardless I found that it was after the surgery that the real pain was to show its true face. Because they waited so long all the muscles and tendants shrunk and were re stretched. Now I was given more of the same pain pills and told to wear a new sling.
    Here it is week 5 and I was told not to wear the sling anymore at home and to wear it only at work. I was also given two exercises to help loosen the shoulder. What I found was that once the sling was off I had absolutely no use of my right arm. I found myself angry and decided since I was on a three day weekend I would work the arm until I got some use back. I can now open doors and drive with the arm but I can not raise the arm up over my head and if I extend the arm I can not get it up to my chin level. The surgeon says I will need therapy so I question now how painful is this therapy and about how long is it?.
    The surgeon says thin people like me complain about the metal and in six months he can remove it. I question what will happen to the arm at that point. Do I go through most of the pain again?
    Im six foot five and used to weigh 160 but since this happened weigh 141 I don’t think I can afford to loose any more weight.
    I have not touched alcohol for fives weeks now and sure wont ever dehydrate myself like that ever again.
    Drinking three or four beers every night and more on weekends made my bones soft. So im told.
    I thank the doctors for telling me every time a person drinks alcohol and then urinates they loose calcium.
    I wonder how many people know this.
    Signed: Thankful to be alive.

  47. Anthony Avatar
    Anthony

    Well where do i start? As i have previously posted on this site I broke my left collar bone on 19th May so I am now in week 9. I really thought I was getting somewhere after my week 6 x-ray showed my bone to be healing ‘nicely’. I went with my in-laws on a canaling holiday last week and using ‘pain’ as a guide I started trying to gently excercise my shoulder. Yet again this was a big mistake as by the time I felt any pain it was too late and I have put my recovery back by a minimum 2 weeks!
    The advice given on this site about pain being a guide does not seem to be correct in my case and I’m getting more and more depressed the longer it goes on! I’m wishing now that I had asked for the operation to have been done at week 3 so at least I could be further down the line to recovery now. I did not break the bone all the way through and was therefore not expecting it to take all this time. I’ve been trying so hard to do NOTHING, but it’s not easy!
    I’m still wondering if a figure 8 brace would keep it more stable? Should I still consider having the op? Is 9+ weeks normal?
    It’s now my busiest time at work, harvest and I,m the only employee who knows how to work a paticular piece of grain machinery, so on top of the frustration of not getting better I feel I’m relly letting my work place down, which is making me feel worse. If the mind is positive then I feel it is easier for the body to heal.
    Any advice would be helpful to try increase my positive mind

    I don’t know if a figure-8 brace will be of use at this point in time. You mention trying not to do anything but finding it hard. Yes, that drove me crazy. So I performed activities in which I didn’t use my shoulder. For example, riding my stationary bike. Rowing was not something I would have considered because of the strain and motion it would apply to my shoulder. You mention feeling you have set yourself back in healing because of the rowing. Was that because of strain on your muscles? It took a lot longer for my muscles to recover from my break than the bone. They would still spasm every so often months later. Massages made the world of difference.

    Having a partial break I would hope and think that you would heal quicker. I haven’t heard of anyone on this site that has had the operation with only a partial break. Your previous examine indicated your bone was healing nicely. That’s a good sign and you are hopefully very close to being recovered. I recommend that you talk with your doctor about your concerns. And speak to your doctor and/or a physical therapist for recovery exercises instead of going at it alone. They will get you going in the right track and you will be healthy again in no time.

  48. Jimmy Avatar
    Jimmy

    Hi,
    Im in week 1 after breaking my right collar bone playing rugby. i’ve hardley had any pain at all. the doctors said it was quite a bad break but there is only a small bump under my skin. the new season starts on 8th of september, i don’t think i’ll be fit to take full contact by then but it’s really frustrating me already!! any advice on how to speed up the healing process??
    Jimmy,
    Halifax,
    West Yorkshire,
    England

    There’s some good advice on healing spread throughout the comments. Eat right, take supplements, and let yourself heal. Yes, it’s frustrating but pushing it too soon and re-injuring yourself will be much more so.

  49. Michael Avatar
    Michael

    I broke my right clavicle June 5 while playing basketball. I think I was intentionally tripped, but who knows. I’m in week 5 1/2 and went to see my doctor at Kaiser today. The bones are not fusing and are actually farther apart! Now I’m being referred to an orthopedic doctor/surgeon. I’ve never had surgery & am really nervous. I also have to go back to work for “light duty”. Any wise words or advice would be appreciated!
    -Mike

    My advice would be to let yourself heal. Don’t try to jump in too soon and over use your shoulder. Use pain as your indicator. Pain is your body telling something is wrong. Oh, and listen to your doctor.

  50. Feeling Dumb Still Avatar
    Feeling Dumb Still

    Well, it’s me again (two posts up). I’m booked in for surgery tomorrow morning (plate+screws). The GP took one look at the xrays and sent me straight back to the Hospital’s fracture clinic. I had my appointment this morning and after looking at some fresh xrays they had me admitted for surgery this afternoon!
    A car accident trauma caused my surgery to be postponed till tomorrow, but I’m still somewhat amazed at the efficiency of the system (I’m in Australia). It sounds like some of you have waited weeks before you even get an xray!
    So I might be setting off alarms on the way through airports from now on.. they said the plate stays in unless it iritates me.
    -Dumb Still

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *